Kierkegaard writes scores of paragraphs critical of pastors under whose watch the church itself is disintegrating. He points out the following problems:
Tietjen, Mark A.. Kierkegaard: A Christian Missionary to Christians
- Pastors’ lives do not reflect their sermons.
- Pastors do not really mean what they preach, so that preaching “jams the lock on imitation” (FSE 261).
- Pastors preach watered-down drivel, and thus they are dishonest about the gospel—its claims and its demands on human life.
- The pastorate is a professional job no different from any other in law, business, medicine and so on. The implications are that some are drawn to the “trade” for secular reasons and thus some pastors have gotten themselves in the wrong business.
- In their sermons pastors promote the view that doctrine matters more than the imitation of Christ; faith is intellectualized.
- Pastors do not understand the world in which they live (i.e., non-Christian forms of existence), nor do they care to, and thus their message is largely irrelevant.
- Pastors offend, but for the wrong sorts of reasons.
The one thing I would add is that “pastors preach for their own benefit.”
